About the Book
Dear God, I'm Tired is Ayanna Elise refusing the performance of strength that organized faith so often demands. Written as a series of direct, unguarded dispatches to God, the memoir is an account of what faith actually looks like when the person holding it is exhausted, doubting, and still showing up anyway. Elise writes from the place most spiritual writing is afraid to go: the moment when prayer feels like talking to a wall, and the person praying keeps going anyway, not from certainty, but from need.
Themes
Discussion Questions
For the Book Club Table
- 01
Elise chooses the epistolary form, writing directly to God, rather than writing about God. What does that choice do for the reader's relationship to the material?
- 02
How does the book handle the tension between faith and doubt? Does Elise resolve that tension, or does she insist on holding both?
- 03
Which letter or dispatch felt most personal to your own experience of faith or spiritual life, and why?
- 04
Elise is honest about moments when prayer felt empty or unanswered. How does she locate meaning in those moments without dismissing them?
- 05
The title suggests exhaustion as a spiritual state rather than a spiritual failure. How does the book make that argument?
- 06
Discuss the relationship between Elise's body and her spiritual practice. How does physical experience shape her theology?
- 07
Who in your life would you want to read this book, and what conversation do you hope it would start?
- 08
Does the book change how you think about what it is acceptable to say to God, or to yourself about your faith?
Personal Reflection
For the Reader Alone
If you were to write your own 'Dear God, I'm Tired' letter, what would be the first sentence? You do not have to share it, just write it.
What is something you have needed to say in the context of your faith or spiritual life that you have never given yourself permission to say?
Elise writes from exhaustion rather than from triumph. Where in your own spiritual journey have you been most tired, and what kept you going?
This book suggests that honesty is a form of worship. Where do you practice that kind of honesty, or where do you avoid it?
Group Activities
For the Circle
Write Your Own Letter
Give each participant ten minutes of quiet to write a brief, honest letter to whatever force, presence, or concept holds spiritual weight for them, it does not have to be the God of Elise's tradition. It can be the universe, a lost person, their own future self. Share only the opening line, or share nothing. Discuss what it felt like to write it.
The Theology of Tired
Make a collective list: what spiritual narratives have you been told about what it means to be exhausted in your faith? Which of those narratives does Elise challenge or confirm? This exercise often surfaces very different received theologies across a group and opens rich conversation about where each person's spiritual formation came from.
The Unanswered Prayer
Each participant thinks of a prayer that was not answered the way they hoped, or a moment when faith felt costly rather than sustaining. They write one sentence about what that experience taught them, even if the lesson was simply that they survived it. Read aloud and discuss: what does Elise's book do with experiences like these that most spiritual texts refuse to acknowledge?
From the Same World
Related Books
Take This Further
Share This Guide With Your Book Club
Contact us to receive a formatted PDF of this guide, or join the Reader Circle for ongoing discussions around this imprint.